18 min read

One Club. Two Teams. Building the Database.

65 players, two squads and plenty of research. Here's how I built Sheffield Wednesday Ladies into Football Manager 27, from real player research and ability ratings to the creation of a 19-player Development squad.

In One Club. Two Teams. A Whole Lot of Wednesday, I introduced the idea behind bringing Sheffield Wednesday’s men’s and women’s teams together in Football Manager 27. Before getting anywhere near starting the save, though, there was a rather large job to complete: building the Sheffield Wednesday women database.

I didn’t want to create a women’s team by adding a collection of names, giving everyone a handful of average attributes and hoping for the best. The aim was to represent the actual players as accurately as the available information allowed.

That meant investigating their footballing backgrounds, finding previous clubs, researching ages, looking at match performances and working out how all of that could translate into Football Manager.

The database now contains 65 players, including a 19-player Development group. I started by researching the senior squad’s names and positions, before expanding the work into ability benchmarks, attributes, personalities, appearance details and a development pathway.

Some players were relatively easy to research, while others required a rather more creative approach. There were plenty of old match reports, club posts and statistical records to work through.

Total players65Across both squads
Development group19Proposed U21 squad
WSL2 median CA98Current Ability benchmark
WSL2 median PA119.5Potential Ability benchmark

Starting with the real club

The starting point was the real Sheffield Wednesday Ladies setup. Rather than create an entirely fictional squad, I wanted to use the players already representing the club and build from there.

The challenge was that information about players at this level isn’t always easy to find. For some players, there are plenty of match reports, appearances and goals to work with. For others, there might only be a handful of mentions across a season, a team sheet or a photograph.

There isn’t a convenient database containing every player’s date of birth, position, preferred foot, height, previous clubs, appearances, goals and playing style. So I had to build my own picture.

Where the research came from

Club reports and match updates were particularly useful for identifying individual contributions. Goals, assists, defensive actions and Player of the Match awards helped me build a picture of how players performed and contributed to the team. Reports and updates from the Sheffield Wednesday Ladies website were among my main sources.

FA Full-Time was another important source, particularly for appearances, goals and Player of the Match awards during the 2025/26 season. The FA Full-Time records helped me understand which players were regular starters, who featured from the bench and how often individuals were involved.

Previous clubs and playing records gave me a better understanding of each player’s experience. I looked beyond their time at Wednesday to build a picture of their footballing journeys and the levels they had played at before joining the club.

Age research was one of the hardest parts. Some players had information available through club announcements, youth football records or other football sources, while others had very little publicly available information.

Photographs and team albums helped with player identification and creating their appearances in the editor. Finding a photograph of the correct player mattered. I didn’t want to use a random image and risk giving someone the wrong face in the database.

Throughout the process, I wanted to use evidence wherever possible and be honest about the gaps. If I couldn’t find reliable information, I’d rather leave something uncertain than present a guess as fact.

Building the First Team

The First Team profiles were built using the same basic format for every player. Each profile included a date of birth or age estimate, Current Ability (CA), Potential Ability (PA), positions and position ratings, and key attributes, and a short explanation of the evidence behind the profile.

This gave me a consistent way to compare players and build the squad.

Current Ability and Potential Ability

One of the biggest challenges was deciding how good each player should be in Football Manager. I wanted to create a squad that could compete at the level we were entering, without making everyone too strong or underestimating players because they currently play outside the professional game.

To give myself a fair reference point, I created two benchmark spreadsheets using player data from Football Manager: one covering the WSL and another covering WSL2.

The WSL2 data was the main reference because that’s the division Sheffield Wednesday Ladies would be joining. The WSL data gave me an idea of the standard we could work towards in the future.

Ability benchmarks
WSL2 median CA98Current Ability
WSL2 median PA119.5Potential Ability
WSL players255Records analysed
WSL2 players168Records analysed

The median is the middle value when all the players are ranked by their rating. So, for example, the WSL2 median CA of 98 gives me a useful idea of the ability level around the middle of that player sample.

These figures weren’t exact targets - I wasn’t expecting every Wednesday player to have a CA of 98 or a PA of 120; they simply gave me a reference point when deciding where each player should sit within the Football Manager ability scale.

I considered each player’s performances, experience, age and individual strengths when deciding their ratings. That meant creating a mixture of established players, developing players and younger prospects with different levels of potential. The aim was to give Sheffield Wednesday Ladies a believable starting squad, with enough room for players to improve over time.

Researching individual players

I didn’t want to base a player’s rating on their name, age or position - I also wanted to look at what they had actually done on the pitch.

A player who regularly scores goals gives me a reason to look more closely at attacking attributes. Someone who creates chances, delivers dangerous crosses or provides assists might need a different profile. A player who makes regular appearances and receives Player of the Match awards may be contributing in ways that aren’t reflected by match stats alone.

Turning match reports into attributes

Match evidenceAttributes to consider
Regular goalscoringFinishing, Off the Ball, Composure
Beating defendersDribbling, Acceleration, Pace
Creating chancesPassing, Vision, Technique
Delivering dangerous crossesCrossing, Technique, Decisions
Strong defensive performancesTackling, Marking, Positioning
Consistent performancesWork Rate, Teamwork, Determination
Leadership and captaincyLeadership, Determination, Teamwork

I used these links between observed performances and possible attributes as a guide, not as proof of a player’s exact values. A player scoring regularly doesn’t automatically have 15 Finishing - the number still needs to fit the wider ability level of the league.

That distinction helped stop the ratings from becoming exaggerated. I wanted standout qualities where the evidence supported them, but didn’t want to turn every positive match report into a collection of high attributes.

Positions: don’t force a player into a role

Another part of building the player profiles was deciding which positions each player should be able to play. I wanted these to reflect their actual playing experience, rather than simply filling in positions to make every profile look complete.

The difficulty was finding reliable evidence of where everyone normally plays. Match reports often tell us who scored, assisted or made an important defensive contribution, but don’t always include a player’s starting position.

For example, seeing someone score a goal from midfield doesn’t automatically mean they’re a striker. Equally, a player making a good defensive contribution doesn’t necessarily tell us whether they started at centre-back or full-back.

Where I could confirm a player’s position through match reports, manager comments or their playing history, I used that information to build their positional profile. Where the evidence wasn’t strong enough, I left the position unassigned.

That might leave a few gaps in the database initially, but I’d rather have an incomplete profile than give someone a position based on guesswork. I can always add more positions and adjust familiarity ratings in the in-game editor as I find better information.

A few First Team profiles that stood out

The research gave me a much better idea of how different players should be represented. Some had clear evidence of their strengths, while others needed a more cautious approach.

Amy Broomhead The goalscorer

Amy was one of the clearest examples of why the research mattered. Her goalscoring record gave me a strong starting point for an attacking profile, but I still wanted to look beyond the total number of goals.

Her records included 44 goals in 22 appearances during 2023/24, followed by 12 goals in 16 appearances in 2024/25 and 10 goals in 17 appearances in 2025/26. Those figures gave me a reason to prioritise Finishing and Off the Ball, while the wider profile also considered Technique and Composure.

I built her working profile around a striker who can find good positions and finish chances, rather than simply giving her high numbers across every attacking attribute.

Nicole Shaw A different kind of forward

Nicole also had a strong goalscoring record, but I didn’t want to give her the same profile as Amy simply because both players score goals.

Manager comments described her as quick and technically gifted, with the ability to use tricks and flicks and take on defenders. A February 2025 club article also described how she could start on the right before moving into central areas.

That gave me evidence for a forward who could operate through the middle or from a wide position. Dribbling, Technique, Flair, Finishing and Off the Ball were among the attributes I considered.

Jodie Stancill The playmaker

Jodie’s experience made her an important reference point when building the midfield. Her background included Wednesday’s youth setup, Sheffield United’s academy and Penistone Church. She returned to Wednesday after a period away from football and became an important senior figure.

Manager comments described her as technically gifted and identified her as the team’s playmaker. That supported a profile built around Passing, Technique, Vision, Decisions and Leadership.

Milly Colford Finding the right pass

Milly offered a different route into the creative midfield role. Her previous clubs included Rotherham United and Swindon Town, and the research included a record of 23 appearances and six goals for Rotherham during 2023/24.

Manager comments compared her playing style to Jodie’s and described her as someone who often finds the pass the team needs. Passing and Vision became the main areas of focus, with Technique, Decisions, First Touch and Teamwork also considered.

Rebekah Pratley Work rate and reliability

Rebekah had some of the clearest evidence for her attitude and commitment. Manager comments described her as a quality centre-half and a training machine who gave 110%.

Match reports added more detail. She made a crucial last-ditch challenge against Thackley, continued after suffering a head injury against York, and contributed from full-back against Farsley with a forward run and low cross that helped create a goal.

As vice-captain, Rebekah also had an important leadership role within the squad. Work Rate was her clearest standout attribute, supported by Determination, Leadership, Teamwork, Tackling and Anticipation. I considered Professionalism separately when building her personality profile, based on the manager’s comments about her attitude and training standards.

Giovanna Petruccelli An international route to Sheffield

Giovanna had one of the more unusual footballing backgrounds in the squad. Born in the USA, her experience included New York Soccer Club, Barca Academy NY Pro, Eastern New York ODP and IDA Sheffield.

She had also captained a regional championship side and played in the Gothia Cup. The manager described her as a gifted left-back with good pace who enjoyed getting forward.

Her debut against Knaresborough in September 2026 provided another example. She made an attacking run into the penalty area and scored in a 2-1 win. I used that evidence as a base for an attack-minded full-back profile, with Pace, Acceleration, Crossing, Passing and Technique receiving attention.

The Development squad: 19 more players

The next big job was building the Development squad - these 19 players are at different stages of their football development. Some have regular first-team involvement, others contribute from the bench, while information about a few players is more limited.

I used the same approach as the First Team, looking at CA, positions, key attributes and available evidence. The main difference was being more cautious about what I could reasonably take from the information available.

Development players 19 Proposed U21 group
Average starting CA 67 Approximate group average

Development player profiles

Some players already have clear strengths and a good amount of evidence behind their profiles. Here are a few who stood out during the research.

Summer Ingham The leading prospect

Starting CA 78

Summer received the highest starting CA in the Development group. She scored 12 goals during 2025/26 and added two more against Dronfield in November 2026.

Her goalscoring record provided the clearest evidence for an attacking profile. Striker was the strongest positional fit, with Finishing, Off the Ball, Acceleration, Composure and Pace among the attributes I focused on.

Anna Greenham Goals and match recognition

Starting CA 73

Anna scored six goals during 2025/26 and collected three Player of the Match awards. That gave me a good reason to place her among the stronger Development players.

Finishing and movement received more attention when building her profile. Her usual position still needs confirming, so I left it unassigned rather than making a guess.

Megan Hammond Creating for others

Starting CA 70

Megan’s performance against Dronfield on 8 November 2026 provided some useful insight. She helped create several goals, delivering the balls for Summer Ingham’s goals and taking the corner that led to Tilly Ironside scoring.

That suggested a player who could create chances for teammates. Rather than focusing on goalscoring, I gave more attention to Passing, Vision, Crossing, Technique and Decisions.

Tiegan Abdy Evidence for a wide role

Starting CA 68

Tiegan scored against Wickersley on 11 October 2026 and was named Player of the Match. The club report described her as a winger who offered a consistent attacking threat.

That gave me enough evidence to consider AMR and AML as suitable positions. Acceleration, Pace and Dribbling were among the main attributes in her starting profile.

Why some Development profiles are more cautious

Not every player had the same amount of information available. Lilly Fletcher made 20 starts and two substitute appearances during 2025/26, while Wendy McCann made 19 starts and four substitute appearances. Kelsey-lee Oliver made 21 starts and one substitute appearance, scoring four goals.

These records showed regular involvement, but didn’t always tell me where a player normally played or which attributes stood out. For players such as Isla Fletcher, Millie Oades and others with limited individual information, I used more balanced starting profiles and left positions unassigned where necessary.

These Development ratings aren’t judgements about the players’ real-life ability - they’re starting points for the Football Manager database. Some profiles are more provisional than others, simply because the amount of evidence available varies from player to player.

Ages and birthdays: filling the gaps

Researching player ages was one of the more difficult parts of the project. Youth football records, club announcements and other football records helped me find useful clues for some First Team players, but reliable information wasn’t available for everyone.

Where I could only establish an approximate age or birth-year range, I recorded an estimate rather than inventing an exact birthday. For Development squad players whose ages I couldn’t confirm, I used realistic placeholder birthdays to give them suitable ages in the FM27 database.

The aim was to fill the gaps without presenting guesses as facts. I’ll update estimated ages and placeholder birthdays if more reliable information becomes available.

Two squads, one development pathway

Once the player profiles were in place, I needed to decide how the club should operate.

I wanted the First Team and Development squad to feel like parts of the same club. The Development side shouldn’t just exist to fill a second fixture list. It should have a clear purpose: helping young players develop and giving them a route into senior football.

I decided to have two squads: the First Team and the U21s.

Player agesProposed contractSquad
15-18YouthU21
19-20Full-timeU21
21+Full-timeFirst Team

The exact contract options will depend on what the editor and competition rules allow, but the idea is to create a natural progression from youth to full-time professional football.

There won’t be a strict age rule for promotion - a player should move into the First Team when their ability and performances justify the opportunity, not simply because they’ve reached a certain birthday.

What the research has taught me

Building a lower-league women’s football database takes patience. Information is spread across club reports, social media, FA Full-Time records, match photographs and previous club histories. But no single source gives us the full picture.

Appearances matter, but context matters too. A player making 20 appearances is clearly involved in the squad, but that doesn’t tell us whether they’re a regular starter, a substitute, a specialist in a particular role or a player being rotated.

Goals aren’t everything either. Summer Ingham’s goals gave me a clear reason to build a strong attacking profile, while Megan Hammond’s creative contribution against Dronfield showed why I shouldn’t judge every player by goals alone.

Perhaps the most important lesson is that unknown information should stay unknown. I could have filled every position and attribute with a guess, but that wouldn’t make the database more accurate. Where evidence was limited, I used cautious estimates or left the information blank.

65 players. One club. A starting point.

What started as a plan to bring Sheffield Wednesday’s women’s team into Football Manager has turned into a much bigger project than I first expected.

There are now 65 players in the database, split between the First Team and a 19-player Development squad. Every profile has been built using the information I could find, with WSL2 benchmarks helping to guide ability ratings and a clear plan for how the two squads should work together.

I've researched playing histories, appearances, goals, ages and positions. I've looked at individual performances, considered attributes and personalities, created player appearances and started putting together a pathway from the U21s into the First Team.

Not every profile is complete. Some positions still need confirming, some birthdays are estimates and some players have more evidence behind their ratings than others. That's fine. I'd rather have a database built on the best information available than one filled with guesses just to make every profile look finished.

Most importantly, we now have something to build on. The aim was never to create an unbeatable team from day one. I want to give Sheffield Wednesday Ladies a believable squad, room for players to develop and a structure that can grow alongside the men's team.

Now comes the interesting part: testing the database

All the research, spreadsheets and player profiles count for very little if the database doesn't work once Football Manager gets hold of it.

Before starting the save properly, I want to run a series of simulations to see how the squads perform over multiple seasons. There are five things I'm particularly interested in:

  1. Do the ratings create a sensible gap between the First Team and U21s?
  2. Have younger players got the potential to develop into senior players?
  3. Are the strongest prospects good enough to make an impact?
  4. Does the contract structure work for both squads?
  5. Can the Development squad produce players who will help Sheffield Wednesday Ladies progress?

If the results highlight problems, I'll go back to the database and make adjustments. That might mean changing individual ratings, reviewing potential ability or looking again at how the two squads are structured. The research gives us a starting point, but the simulations will show whether the work holds up in the game.

We're not quite ready to start the save yet. But we're getting closer.

One club. Two teams. And now, 65 players who have a place in the story. Next up, it's time to find out whether I've built a squad capable of making this idea work.